The United SpongeBob Forums

Off Topic => Everything Else => Debate Den => Topic started by: Banana on June 30, 2005, 01:14:32 pm

Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Banana on June 30, 2005, 01:14:32 pm
What is your stance on this currently quite controverisal subject?

-Banana
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Elizabeth Rose on June 30, 2005, 03:32:36 pm
I don't see a problem with it, this a country where all religions are supposedly tolerated. If we can have a ton of other religious symbols on display, why not let Christians have the Ten Commandments on public display?
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: ssj4gogita4 on June 30, 2005, 03:34:02 pm
Ok, I know people would get offended if they became readable in public. but ya know what...they dont have to read them. It's there for the people who want to, mainly Christians.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Elizabeth Rose on June 30, 2005, 03:41:34 pm
Quote
Ok, I know people would get offended if they became readable in public. but ya know what...they dont have to read them. It's there for the people who want to, mainly Christians.
[snapback]199447[/snapback]
Exactly. It's kinda like at Christmas when the Menorah, and the Kwanzaa candlestick (Sorry, I forget the name.) are displayed, as well as a Nativity scene. It's a part of freedom.

As for being "offended" by the Ten Commandments? Come on. Most of them are just good common sense anyway. Nothing offensive about being told not to steal, or cheat of your spouse, etc...
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: ssj4gogita4 on June 30, 2005, 03:46:54 pm
Well, yes, they are common sense but I bet 40-50% of the population in US would get offended and complain to our government, which in turn, would probably do something to the pledge of allegiance.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on June 30, 2005, 03:47:59 pm
Unless you plan to display every single religion out there, none should be up.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: super_sayian_spongebob on June 30, 2005, 04:35:55 pm
Well it's not there for a religious purpose, so it should be up.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: jesusofsuburbia on June 30, 2005, 04:52:47 pm
Quote
Well it's not there for a religious purpose, so it should be up.
[snapback]199481[/snapback]

If not religious, would you care to explain for what purpose are they going to be displayed?
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: super_sayian_spongebob on June 30, 2005, 04:54:54 pm
Explain why there is something mentioning the declaration of independence and other documents right below it.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: jesusofsuburbia on June 30, 2005, 05:01:08 pm
Quote
Explain why there is something mentioning the declaration of independence and other documents right below it.
[snapback]199497[/snapback]

I truly don't care about the other documents. You say the ten commandments are or will be up there for non-religious purposes, and to me, they're a symbol of the Christian religion. So that's why I want to know, what is the purpose then?
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: oscar_the_grouch on June 30, 2005, 05:05:24 pm
It really doesn't bother me as long as you aren't being a bible thumper and shoving it in my face.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Elizabeth Rose on June 30, 2005, 05:07:42 pm
Quote
Unless you plan to display every single religion out there, none should be up.
[snapback]199462[/snapback]
Anyone who wants to should be able to.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Snowthrower on June 30, 2005, 06:04:43 pm
As I say: Just because you dont like it, other people may. Shut up and deal with it.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Sheldon J. Plankton on June 30, 2005, 06:07:18 pm
The same word repeated 3 times: No, no, no. There are a lot of people with other religions who would be offended.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: GrEeNdAyFrEaK on June 30, 2005, 06:59:06 pm
How is it offensive? It's a list of ten rules given from the Bible. It doesn't say "Everyone must follow these rules:" or "Become a Christian", it's just a list of rules that has a significant meaning to some and none to others. Anyone should be able to post whatever religious documents they want as long as it isnt vulgar.

http://www.harrodsburgherald.com/0headlines.html (http://www.harrodsburgherald.com/0headlines.html) Clip from our local newspaper - at least we're still winning the battle  :happy:
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Elizabeth Rose on June 30, 2005, 07:38:07 pm
Quote
The same word repeated 3 times: No, no, no. There are a lot of people with other religions who would be offended.
[snapback]199540[/snapback]
What if I decide that the Menorah offends me? See how ridiculous that is? Once again, ANYONE should be able to display ANY religious symbol as long as it isn't something horribly vulgar, in which case, it isn't likely religious.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: MEEP! on June 30, 2005, 08:30:40 pm
Quote
Quote
The same word repeated 3 times: No, no, no. There are a lot of people with other religions who would be offended.
[snapback]199540[/snapback]
What if I decide that the Menorah offends me? See how ridiculous that is? Once again, ANYONE should be able to display ANY religious symbol as long as it isn't something horribly vulgar, in which case, it isn't likely religious.
[snapback]199572[/snapback]


I have to agree with you. I'm fine with other religions putting up stuff of their's. It's a free country.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: timstapels on July 01, 2005, 01:40:49 am
I don't really mind, I don't see why people should get offended by it when it's not the law to follow the rules or anything.

I must admit, living in New Zealand (or maybe it's just me), I don't know a heck of alot of info about the ten commandments.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Eva:Gina on July 01, 2005, 07:50:10 am
yeah, its like displaying a statue of a scottish relitive, and the clan he this relative may have been fueding against tells you to take it down.

its not good enough to not be abusive against other cultures, you should relish them!!

i mean, teachign in schools is different, its forcing belifs onto people, but displaying proud symbols, as long as every other religion can as well, is jsut haivng pride on your beleifs!!
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: super_sayian_spongebob on July 01, 2005, 09:37:35 am
When I went to Poland they do stuff like this. The sometimes make prayers on the radio stations at 3pm, but no one who isn't Christian complains they just deal with it. Here everyone gets angry about it because they don't believe in such things. I'm afraid if this country gets going like this we would end up having a long civil war.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: GrEeNdAyFrEaK on July 01, 2005, 10:51:25 am
We're not going to have a civil war... I don't know why people are so set on believing we will...
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 01, 2005, 11:11:52 am
Quote
Explain why there is something mentioning the declaration of independence and other documents right below it.
[snapback]199497[/snapback]

That's because those documents are dealing with American Independance, something that is actually real.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: GrEeNdAyFrEaK on July 01, 2005, 11:21:19 am
Quote
That's because those documents are dealing with American Independance, something that is actually real.
[snapback]199847[/snapback]
If you're implying that the Ten Commandments arent real, which is guessing you are, then why do you have a problem with it being posted publicly? It's not telling you to do anything, it's just something hanging on the wall that doesn't apply to you if you don't want it to.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Elizabeth Rose on July 01, 2005, 03:21:49 pm
Quote
Quote
Explain why there is something mentioning the declaration of independence and other documents right below it.
[snapback]199497[/snapback]

That's because those documents are dealing with American Independance, something that is actually real.
[snapback]199847[/snapback]
You dissapoint me. You surely cannot say just because you don't think something is "real" makes it no good. Everyone knows it is wrong to lie, steal, murder, cheat, etc...
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Roger on July 01, 2005, 03:31:35 pm
My town is (I'm pretty sure) the only town in the United States that has the Ten Commandments posted in the courthouse.  The reason they were able to?  They posted it alongside the Magna Carta, Constitution, Hammurabi's Code, the Mayflower Compact, and a few other documents which are there to show the basis of laws.

I don't see a problem with the Ten Commandments being displayed in public.  Most of them are rule EVERYONE should live by, no matter what your religion.  Sure there are a couple that non-Christians don't have to pay attention to, but everyone should be living by the rule of "Thou shall not kill," and the others.  

Besides, it's not really the issue of whether they can be displayed in public, as much as whether they can be displayed in government buildings.  Heck, there's a building in my town that has the Ten Commandments in a huge sign on the side of the building.  About 98% of the buildings in this county have the Ten Commandments in them somewhere, despite the large amount of non-Christians who live here.  Nobody seems to really have a problem with it.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: super_sayian_spongebob on July 02, 2005, 11:52:42 am
Quote
Quote
Explain why there is something mentioning the declaration of independence and other documents right below it.
[snapback]199497[/snapback]

That's because those documents are dealing with American Independance, something that is actually real.
[snapback]199847[/snapback]
If so, then you should let them display it then anyway.

P.S Hey IZ, the ten commandments are real. Probably without them none of us would be posting because everyone would be killing each other.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Eva:Gina on July 03, 2005, 12:56:05 am
i think the big cheezez courthouse has hte right idea, all the cultures saying hte same thing, shows..... that word which i cant remeber right now,,,,,, but you know what im saying...

(gtimices, useless post... :biggrin: )
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 03, 2005, 09:07:14 am
Quote
Quote
Quote
Explain why there is something mentioning the declaration of independence and other documents right below it.
[snapback]199497[/snapback]

That's because those documents are dealing with American Independance, something that is actually real.
[snapback]199847[/snapback]
If so, then you should let them display it then anyway.

P.S Hey IZ, the ten commandments are real. Probably without them none of us would be posting because everyone would be killing each other.
[snapback]200382[/snapback]

People still kill each other.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Spongefan123 on July 03, 2005, 10:19:09 am
Quote
How is it offensive? It's a list of ten rules given from the Bible. It doesn't say "Everyone must follow these rules:" or "Become a Christian", it's just a list of rules that has a significant meaning to some and none to others. Anyone should be able to post whatever religious documents they want as long as it isnt vulgar.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: super_sayian_spongebob on July 04, 2005, 09:12:24 am
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Explain why there is something mentioning the declaration of independence and other documents right below it.
[snapback]199497[/snapback]

That's because those documents are dealing with American Independance, something that is actually real.
[snapback]199847[/snapback]
If so, then you should let them display it then anyway.

P.S Hey IZ, the ten commandments are real. Probably without them none of us would be posting because everyone would be killing each other.
[snapback]200382[/snapback]

People still kill each other.
[snapback]200876[/snapback]
That's because they don't listen.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: ssj4gogita4 on July 04, 2005, 09:19:15 am
Its because they dont care.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: oscar_the_grouch on July 04, 2005, 10:16:17 pm
Displaying the Ten Comandments in public is much like the gay pride parade. Not everyone is going to like it, not everyone is going to suport it, some frown apon it, but its still going to happen.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Hannahbal on July 05, 2005, 12:49:23 pm
I think it's fine just as long as other documents from other religions can be posted.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Sheldon J. Plankton on July 06, 2005, 01:32:17 pm
Quote
Quote
The same word repeated 3 times: No, no, no. There are a lot of people with other religions who would be offended.
[snapback]199540[/snapback]
What if I decide that the Menorah offends me? See how ridiculous that is? Once again, ANYONE should be able to display ANY religious symbol as long as it isn't something horribly vulgar, in which case, it isn't likely religious.
[snapback]199572[/snapback]

No they shouldn't. What they're implying by putting up religious symbols in public is that everyone is of that religion. It offends people who are not Christian because it makes them feel inferior. Believe me, I have a lot of friends who are not Christian (Jewish and various assorted Asian religions), and they are offended by this sort of thing.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Elizabeth Rose on July 06, 2005, 02:22:29 pm
Quote
Quote
Quote
The same word repeated 3 times: No, no, no. There are a lot of people with other religions who would be offended.
[snapback]199540[/snapback]
What if I decide that the Menorah offends me? See how ridiculous that is? Once again, ANYONE should be able to display ANY religious symbol as long as it isn't something horribly vulgar, in which case, it isn't likely religious.
[snapback]199572[/snapback]

No they shouldn't. What they're implying by putting up religious symbols in public is that everyone is of that religion. It offends people who are not Christian because it makes them feel inferior. Believe me, I have a lot of friends who are not Christian (Jewish and various assorted Asian religions), and they are offended by this sort of thing.
[snapback]202522[/snapback]
Well they need to get over it. There is nothing there to make anyone feel inferior. In America, we are priviledged to put up any and all religious symbols. They can display theirs, the Christian down the road can display his.

You have Jewish friends insulted by the Ten Commandments, put out there by Moses himself? Nice try, bud. No Jew is offended by God or Moses.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 06, 2005, 02:47:43 pm
It's not necessarily you wanting to put something up in your personal business, it's when they put them up in government buildings that makes me mad.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Fink on July 07, 2005, 10:42:12 am
Quote
Quote
Explain why there is something mentioning the declaration of independence and other documents right below it.
[snapback]199497[/snapback]

That's because those documents are dealing with American Independance, something that is actually real.
[snapback]199847[/snapback]

So you're stating that the Ten Commandments are offending to some. What you just posted was hyporcrisy, from my point of view. That's offending to Christians, and things like that are said everywhere. I think it's a fair share of people getting offended anyway. Any other religion doesn't have to follow the ten commandments, it's displayed for the people that actually care. I was going through Xanga one day and found this site of two girls that thought it would be so cool to make a completely offensive post in their blog. It isn't even a blog, it's just that one post. Here is the link: http://www.xanga.com/home.aspx?user=Super__Sinners (http://www.xanga.com/home.aspx?user=Super__Sinners)

Hence the name. There are things that are said like that everywhere,  you either choose to be offended by it or shake it off and continue to live for what you believe, no questions asked.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 07, 2005, 11:41:40 am
Why do you need them displayed anyway? Shouldn't you already know them?

It's the commandments like "You shall have no other gods besides Me" that make me disagree with posting it in public. You're basically spitting in the face of every other religion.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: GrEeNdAyFrEaK on July 07, 2005, 12:07:50 pm
Quote
Why do you need them displayed anyway? Shouldn't you already know them?

It's the commandments like "You shall have no other gods besides Me" that make me disagree with posting it in public. You're basically spitting in the face of every other religion.
[snapback]203085[/snapback]
If you're going with that argument then you're saying signs shouldn't be up during elections, either.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: super_sayian_spongebob on July 07, 2005, 01:06:08 pm
Quote
Why do you need them displayed anyway? Shouldn't you already know them?

It's the commandments like "You shall have no other gods besides Me" that make me disagree with posting it in public. You're basically spitting in the face of every other religion.
[snapback]203085[/snapback]
They can just ignore it. That's what I would do if I wasn't Christian.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Sheldon J. Plankton on July 07, 2005, 02:06:51 pm
Quote
Why do you need them displayed anyway? Shouldn't you already know them?

It's the commandments like "You shall have no other gods besides Me" that make me disagree with posting it in public. You're basically spitting in the face of every other religion.
[snapback]203085[/snapback]

Thats what I've been trying to say.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 07, 2005, 04:51:36 pm
Quote
Quote
Why do you need them displayed anyway? Shouldn't you already know them?

It's the commandments like "You shall have no other gods besides Me" that make me disagree with posting it in public. You're basically spitting in the face of every other religion.
[snapback]203085[/snapback]
They can just ignore it. That's what I would do if I wasn't Christian.
[snapback]203132[/snapback]

You are Christian though, you don't know what it's like to have one religion massively favored throughout the government.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Hannahbal on July 07, 2005, 08:30:27 pm
Yeah actually every one kind of does look down upon you if you tell them you aren't christian. I don't know how to explain it.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: ssj4gogita4 on July 07, 2005, 08:39:34 pm
Quote
Yeah actually every one kind of does look down upon you if you tell them you aren't christian. I don't know how to explain it.
[snapback]203423[/snapback]
Not everyone will. Some people will accept that...like me.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Hannahbal on July 07, 2005, 08:40:06 pm
Well, of course I was exaggerating. Mostly everyone I know doesn't accept it.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Eva:Gina on July 07, 2005, 10:25:10 pm
Quote
Quote
Why do you need them displayed anyway? Shouldn't you already know them?

It's the commandments like "You shall have no other gods besides Me" that make me disagree with posting it in public. You're basically spitting in the face of every other religion.
[snapback]203085[/snapback]
If you're going with that argument then you're saying signs shouldn't be up during elections, either.
[snapback]203099[/snapback]
that bush got through, despite his barbaric behaviour and racism, just cos hes christian, is wrong.

i agree IZ, i mean, you cant really display nine of the ten commandments, but thats not cool.
it could make a muslim in the couthouse feel that he was going to get less of a fair go than he should.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Fink on July 08, 2005, 10:23:53 pm
Quote
Well, of course I was exaggerating. Mostly everyone I know doesn't accept it.
[snapback]203428[/snapback]

That's sort of how I feel, but the abuse is coming from protestants (actually Baptist, no offence to anyone, I realize there are more considerate ones out there). Sure, because of my religion, but most is because they think they're better than my church because they have more money. Honestly, I sort of agree with how Kerry (although HE was Catholic) was not going to interfere with a non-christian's life. You know what I mean right? It's just something people have to go through. There isn't anything we can do really.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Eva:Gina on July 09, 2005, 02:01:12 am
its so pathetic. the whole hatred becuase of beleifs thing.

put it this way , fink (i used you cos your the only ohter poster on this page) i hate greenday, i think they have produced a totally crappy cd.
great, do you care what i think?? no

and i dont care that you like them. as long as i dont have to listen to it.

so, i feel the same way about religion, ta da!!! :biggrin:
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: cs@charter.net on July 09, 2005, 07:37:34 pm
Lots of things offend people, why is it that they just want the ten commandments taken down? It should be all right. If you don't like it, DON'T LOOK AT IT!!! DUH!! Is it that hard? They are commandments given by God that we should follow! John Kerry signs offend many of us (me, anyway), yet we tolerate them. What's the difference in the ten commandments?
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 09, 2005, 07:49:29 pm
Quote
Lots of things offend people, why is it that they just want the ten commandments taken down? It should be all right. If you don't like it, DON'T LOOK AT IT!!! DUH!! Is it that hard? They are commandments given by God that we should follow! John Kerry signs offend many of us (me, anyway), yet we tolerate them. What's the difference in the ten commandments?
[snapback]204299[/snapback]

You're entitled freedom of religion in the constitution, you're not entitled to remove anything and everything that offends you.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Roger on July 23, 2005, 11:37:16 am
Quote
You're entitled freedom of religion in the constitution, you're not entitled to remove anything and everything that offends you.
[snapback]204304[/snapback]

Yeah...I'm bringing back an old topic...but I have a point....so yeah.

Kevin...what you said there totally contradicts what you said earlier in the argument.  You said you don't support the posting of the the Ten Commandments, but you also say you don't have the right to remove stuff that is offensive to you.  So...you don't have the right to keep the Ten Commandments from being posted.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 23, 2005, 12:08:29 pm
Quote
Quote
You're entitled freedom of religion in the constitution, you're not entitled to remove anything and everything that offends you.
[snapback]204304[/snapback]

Yeah...I'm bringing back an old topic...but I have a point....so yeah.

Kevin...what you said there totally contradicts what you said earlier in the argument.  You said you don't support the posting of the the Ten Commandments, but you also say you don't have the right to remove stuff that is offensive to you.  So...you don't have the right to keep the Ten Commandments from being posted.
[snapback]209018[/snapback]

No, he said Kerry posters are offensive and should be removed because "they offend him". Elections are competition though, religion isn't. You do have the right to the freedom of religion though, and "You shall have no other Gods before me." is a slap in the face to every other religion out there. Election posters are just insulting your political choice, while the 10 Commandments insult your entire way of life.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Roger on July 23, 2005, 12:14:25 pm
Quote
Quote
Quote
You're entitled freedom of religion in the constitution, you're not entitled to remove anything and everything that offends you.
[snapback]204304[/snapback]

Yeah...I'm bringing back an old topic...but I have a point....so yeah.

Kevin...what you said there totally contradicts what you said earlier in the argument.  You said you don't support the posting of the the Ten Commandments, but you also say you don't have the right to remove stuff that is offensive to you.  So...you don't have the right to keep the Ten Commandments from being posted.
[snapback]209018[/snapback]

No, he said Kerry posters are offensive and should be removed because "they offend him". Elections are competition though, religion isn't. You do have the right to the freedom of religion though, and "You shall have no other Gods before me." is a slap in the face to every other religion out there. Election posters are just insulting your political choice, while the 10 Commandments insult your entire way of life.
[snapback]209041[/snapback]

How can they insult your way of life?  They simply show the way some people (some happens to be most in the U.S.A) choose to live.  If you don't like what they say, you don't HAVE to look.  You have the freedom not to.  

You call it a "slap in the face," but you don't bother to look at the fact that whatever you believe is also a slap in the face to Christians.

EDIT: Oh yes, I forgot my other point...

He may have said Kerry posters offended him, but you used the same logic for the Ten Commandments.  There's a fault in your logic there.  You find the Ten Commandments offensive and don't want them displayed.  He found Kerry posters offensive and didn't want them displayed.  It works both ways.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 23, 2005, 12:17:12 pm
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
You're entitled freedom of religion in the constitution, you're not entitled to remove anything and everything that offends you.
[snapback]204304[/snapback]

Yeah...I'm bringing back an old topic...but I have a point....so yeah.

Kevin...what you said there totally contradicts what you said earlier in the argument.  You said you don't support the posting of the the Ten Commandments, but you also say you don't have the right to remove stuff that is offensive to you.  So...you don't have the right to keep the Ten Commandments from being posted.
[snapback]209018[/snapback]

No, he said Kerry posters are offensive and should be removed because "they offend him". Elections are competition though, religion isn't. You do have the right to the freedom of religion though, and "You shall have no other Gods before me." is a slap in the face to every other religion out there. Election posters are just insulting your political choice, while the 10 Commandments insult your entire way of life.
[snapback]209041[/snapback]

How can they insult your way of life?  They simply show the way some people (some happens to be most in the U.S.A) choose to live.  If you don't like what they say, you don't HAVE to look.  You have the freedom not to.  

You call it a "slap in the face," but you don't bother to look at the fact that whatever you believe is also a slap in the face to Christians.
[snapback]209044[/snapback]

but when you put the Ten Commandments in goverment buildings and courthouses, you're saying that the governments thinks what you're doing is wrong, and that's not fair.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Roger on July 23, 2005, 12:20:27 pm
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
You're entitled freedom of religion in the constitution, you're not entitled to remove anything and everything that offends you.
[snapback]204304[/snapback]

Yeah...I'm bringing back an old topic...but I have a point....so yeah.

Kevin...what you said there totally contradicts what you said earlier in the argument.  You said you don't support the posting of the the Ten Commandments, but you also say you don't have the right to remove stuff that is offensive to you.  So...you don't have the right to keep the Ten Commandments from being posted.
[snapback]209018[/snapback]

No, he said Kerry posters are offensive and should be removed because "they offend him". Elections are competition though, religion isn't. You do have the right to the freedom of religion though, and "You shall have no other Gods before me." is a slap in the face to every other religion out there. Election posters are just insulting your political choice, while the 10 Commandments insult your entire way of life.
[snapback]209041[/snapback]

How can they insult your way of life?  They simply show the way some people (some happens to be most in the U.S.A) choose to live.  If you don't like what they say, you don't HAVE to look.  You have the freedom not to.  

You call it a "slap in the face," but you don't bother to look at the fact that whatever you believe is also a slap in the face to Christians.
[snapback]209044[/snapback]

but when you put the Ten Commandments in goverment buildings and courthouses, you're saying that the governments thinks what you're doing is wrong, and that's not fair.
[snapback]209045[/snapback]

Does it say anywhere that the government thinks you are wrong?  No.

If you get right down to the reason this country was founded...it was religious freedom.  But it's not how we think of it now.  Religious freedom to the founders of the U.S. meant freedom from the Church of England.  They wanted to keep the same basic beliefs, but change some of the corruption of the church.  So, when talking about things which helped shape the foundation of our country, the Ten Commandments are crucial.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 23, 2005, 12:22:04 pm
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
You're entitled freedom of religion in the constitution, you're not entitled to remove anything and everything that offends you.
[snapback]204304[/snapback]

Yeah...I'm bringing back an old topic...but I have a point....so yeah.

Kevin...what you said there totally contradicts what you said earlier in the argument.  You said you don't support the posting of the the Ten Commandments, but you also say you don't have the right to remove stuff that is offensive to you.  So...you don't have the right to keep the Ten Commandments from being posted.
[snapback]209018[/snapback]

No, he said Kerry posters are offensive and should be removed because "they offend him". Elections are competition though, religion isn't. You do have the right to the freedom of religion though, and "You shall have no other Gods before me." is a slap in the face to every other religion out there. Election posters are just insulting your political choice, while the 10 Commandments insult your entire way of life.
[snapback]209041[/snapback]

How can they insult your way of life?  They simply show the way some people (some happens to be most in the U.S.A) choose to live.  If you don't like what they say, you don't HAVE to look.  You have the freedom not to.  

You call it a "slap in the face," but you don't bother to look at the fact that whatever you believe is also a slap in the face to Christians.
[snapback]209044[/snapback]

but when you put the Ten Commandments in goverment buildings and courthouses, you're saying that the governments thinks what you're doing is wrong, and that's not fair.
[snapback]209045[/snapback]

Does it say anywhere that the government thinks you are wrong?  No.

If you get right down to the reason this country was founded...it was religious freedom.  But it's not how we think of it now.  Religious freedom to the founders of the U.S. meant freedom from the Church of England.  They wanted to keep the same basic beliefs, but change some of the corruption of the church.  So, when talking about things which helped shape the foundation of our country, the Ten Commandments are crucial.
[snapback]209046[/snapback]

It doesn't matter what the founders thought though. They thought slavery was acceptable, is that still true today? The founders were great people for what they did, but some of their beliefs are outdated and wrong.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Roger on July 23, 2005, 12:28:26 pm
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
You're entitled freedom of religion in the constitution, you're not entitled to remove anything and everything that offends you.
[snapback]204304[/snapback]

Yeah...I'm bringing back an old topic...but I have a point....so yeah.

Kevin...what you said there totally contradicts what you said earlier in the argument.  You said you don't support the posting of the the Ten Commandments, but you also say you don't have the right to remove stuff that is offensive to you.  So...you don't have the right to keep the Ten Commandments from being posted.
[snapback]209018[/snapback]

No, he said Kerry posters are offensive and should be removed because "they offend him". Elections are competition though, religion isn't. You do have the right to the freedom of religion though, and "You shall have no other Gods before me." is a slap in the face to every other religion out there. Election posters are just insulting your political choice, while the 10 Commandments insult your entire way of life.
[snapback]209041[/snapback]

How can they insult your way of life?  They simply show the way some people (some happens to be most in the U.S.A) choose to live.  If you don't like what they say, you don't HAVE to look.  You have the freedom not to.  

You call it a "slap in the face," but you don't bother to look at the fact that whatever you believe is also a slap in the face to Christians.
[snapback]209044[/snapback]

but when you put the Ten Commandments in goverment buildings and courthouses, you're saying that the governments thinks what you're doing is wrong, and that's not fair.
[snapback]209045[/snapback]

Does it say anywhere that the government thinks you are wrong?  No.

If you get right down to the reason this country was founded...it was religious freedom.  But it's not how we think of it now.  Religious freedom to the founders of the U.S. meant freedom from the Church of England.  They wanted to keep the same basic beliefs, but change some of the corruption of the church.  So, when talking about things which helped shape the foundation of our country, the Ten Commandments are crucial.
[snapback]209046[/snapback]

It doesn't matter what the founders thought though. They thought slavery was acceptable, is that still true today? The founders were great people for what they did, but some of their beliefs are outdated and wrong.
[snapback]209047[/snapback]

Okay, let's get extremely technical.  The founders of our country DIDN'T think slavery was acceptable.  It was a separatist group from the south that thought that.

Times were a bit simpler back then.  People didn't read much into what was written in the Constitution, so everything had a meaning which has been stretched now.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 23, 2005, 12:30:19 pm
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
You're entitled freedom of religion in the constitution, you're not entitled to remove anything and everything that offends you.
[snapback]204304[/snapback]

Yeah...I'm bringing back an old topic...but I have a point....so yeah.

Kevin...what you said there totally contradicts what you said earlier in the argument.  You said you don't support the posting of the the Ten Commandments, but you also say you don't have the right to remove stuff that is offensive to you.  So...you don't have the right to keep the Ten Commandments from being posted.
[snapback]209018[/snapback]

No, he said Kerry posters are offensive and should be removed because "they offend him". Elections are competition though, religion isn't. You do have the right to the freedom of religion though, and "You shall have no other Gods before me." is a slap in the face to every other religion out there. Election posters are just insulting your political choice, while the 10 Commandments insult your entire way of life.
[snapback]209041[/snapback]

How can they insult your way of life?  They simply show the way some people (some happens to be most in the U.S.A) choose to live.  If you don't like what they say, you don't HAVE to look.  You have the freedom not to.  

You call it a "slap in the face," but you don't bother to look at the fact that whatever you believe is also a slap in the face to Christians.
[snapback]209044[/snapback]

but when you put the Ten Commandments in goverment buildings and courthouses, you're saying that the governments thinks what you're doing is wrong, and that's not fair.
[snapback]209045[/snapback]

Does it say anywhere that the government thinks you are wrong?  No.

If you get right down to the reason this country was founded...it was religious freedom.  But it's not how we think of it now.  Religious freedom to the founders of the U.S. meant freedom from the Church of England.  They wanted to keep the same basic beliefs, but change some of the corruption of the church.  So, when talking about things which helped shape the foundation of our country, the Ten Commandments are crucial.
[snapback]209046[/snapback]

It doesn't matter what the founders thought though. They thought slavery was acceptable, is that still true today? The founders were great people for what they did, but some of their beliefs are outdated and wrong.
[snapback]209047[/snapback]

Okay, let's get extremely technical.  The founders of our country DIDN'T think slavery was acceptable.  It was a separatist group from the south that thought that.

Times were a bit simpler back then.  People didn't read much into what was written in the Constitution, so everything had a meaning which has been stretched now.
[snapback]209051[/snapback]

Okay, but that still doesn't change the fact that even if they thought Christianity was the only important religion, they were wrong.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Rocko on July 23, 2005, 12:31:53 pm
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
You're entitled freedom of religion in the constitution, you're not entitled to remove anything and everything that offends you.
[snapback]204304[/snapback]

Yeah...I'm bringing back an old topic...but I have a point....so yeah.

Kevin...what you said there totally contradicts what you said earlier in the argument.  You said you don't support the posting of the the Ten Commandments, but you also say you don't have the right to remove stuff that is offensive to you.  So...you don't have the right to keep the Ten Commandments from being posted.
[snapback]209018[/snapback]

No, he said Kerry posters are offensive and should be removed because "they offend him". Elections are competition though, religion isn't. You do have the right to the freedom of religion though, and "You shall have no other Gods before me." is a slap in the face to every other religion out there. Election posters are just insulting your political choice, while the 10 Commandments insult your entire way of life.
[snapback]209041[/snapback]

How can they insult your way of life?  They simply show the way some people (some happens to be most in the U.S.A) choose to live.  If you don't like what they say, you don't HAVE to look.  You have the freedom not to.  

You call it a "slap in the face," but you don't bother to look at the fact that whatever you believe is also a slap in the face to Christians.
[snapback]209044[/snapback]

but when you put the Ten Commandments in goverment buildings and courthouses, you're saying that the governments thinks what you're doing is wrong, and that's not fair.
[snapback]209045[/snapback]

Does it say anywhere that the government thinks you are wrong?  No.

If you get right down to the reason this country was founded...it was religious freedom.  But it's not how we think of it now.  Religious freedom to the founders of the U.S. meant freedom from the Church of England.  They wanted to keep the same basic beliefs, but change some of the corruption of the church.  So, when talking about things which helped shape the foundation of our country, the Ten Commandments are crucial.
[snapback]209046[/snapback]

It doesn't matter what the founders thought though. They thought slavery was acceptable, is that still true today? The founders were great people for what they did, but some of their beliefs are outdated and wrong.
[snapback]209047[/snapback]
Besides there is seperation of church and state. And anything relating to the church cannot be sponsered or displayed by the goverment.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Roger on July 23, 2005, 12:40:25 pm
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
You're entitled freedom of religion in the constitution, you're not entitled to remove anything and everything that offends you.
[snapback]204304[/snapback]

Yeah...I'm bringing back an old topic...but I have a point....so yeah.

Kevin...what you said there totally contradicts what you said earlier in the argument.  You said you don't support the posting of the the Ten Commandments, but you also say you don't have the right to remove stuff that is offensive to you.  So...you don't have the right to keep the Ten Commandments from being posted.
[snapback]209018[/snapback]

No, he said Kerry posters are offensive and should be removed because "they offend him". Elections are competition though, religion isn't. You do have the right to the freedom of religion though, and "You shall have no other Gods before me." is a slap in the face to every other religion out there. Election posters are just insulting your political choice, while the 10 Commandments insult your entire way of life.
[snapback]209041[/snapback]

How can they insult your way of life?  They simply show the way some people (some happens to be most in the U.S.A) choose to live.  If you don't like what they say, you don't HAVE to look.  You have the freedom not to.  

You call it a "slap in the face," but you don't bother to look at the fact that whatever you believe is also a slap in the face to Christians.
[snapback]209044[/snapback]

but when you put the Ten Commandments in goverment buildings and courthouses, you're saying that the governments thinks what you're doing is wrong, and that's not fair.
[snapback]209045[/snapback]

Does it say anywhere that the government thinks you are wrong?  No.

If you get right down to the reason this country was founded...it was religious freedom.  But it's not how we think of it now.  Religious freedom to the founders of the U.S. meant freedom from the Church of England.  They wanted to keep the same basic beliefs, but change some of the corruption of the church.  So, when talking about things which helped shape the foundation of our country, the Ten Commandments are crucial.
[snapback]209046[/snapback]

It doesn't matter what the founders thought though. They thought slavery was acceptable, is that still true today? The founders were great people for what they did, but some of their beliefs are outdated and wrong.
[snapback]209047[/snapback]

Okay, let's get extremely technical.  The founders of our country DIDN'T think slavery was acceptable.  It was a separatist group from the south that thought that.

Times were a bit simpler back then.  People didn't read much into what was written in the Constitution, so everything had a meaning which has been stretched now.
[snapback]209051[/snapback]

Okay, but that still doesn't change the fact that even if they thought Christianity was the only important religion, they were wrong.
[snapback]209053[/snapback]

Does it say anywhere that Christianity is the only important religion?  Did I say it? No.  I'm simply saying that the posting of the Ten Commandments has absolutely no impact on anyone religiously if you look at it through the history of the U.S.  

If people keep in mind the basis of the U.S.A, then there should be no problems with the Ten Commandments.  People read too much into stuff nowadays.  That's why the Ten Commandments has become such an issue.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Elizabeth Rose on July 23, 2005, 12:57:49 pm
Quote
Besides there is seperation of church and state. And anything relating to the church cannot be sponsered or displayed by the goverment.

Sorry, but no. Separation of church and state means there cannot be an established national religion. For example: The Church of England. Separation of church and state DOES NOT mean religious symbols can't be on government property.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 23, 2005, 01:01:18 pm
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

That says more than not being able to set up a state religion.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Roger on July 23, 2005, 01:02:55 pm
Wow.  I read the last couple of posts wrong...and typed my answer even worse...so just forget I posted.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Elizabeth Rose on July 23, 2005, 01:10:16 pm
Quote
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

That says more than not being able to set up a state religion.
[snapback]209076[/snapback]
Wow, you are helping me out.

Let's be a little clearer. Separation of Church and State: The government cannot control the church.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on July 23, 2005, 01:11:55 pm
Quote
Quote
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

That says more than not being able to set up a state religion.
[snapback]209076[/snapback]
Wow, you are helping me out.

Let's be a little clearer. Separation of Church and State: The government cannot control the church.
[snapback]209087[/snapback]

and the church cannot control the government.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Roger on July 23, 2005, 01:13:35 pm
Quote
Let's be a little clearer. Separation of Church and State: The government cannot control the church.
[snapback]209087[/snapback]

Exactly.

I know someone is going to say that means the Ten Commandments can't be posted...but that's not what it means.

It means that the government can't say "We have a Church of the United States of America, and you must follow its practices."

Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Elizabeth Rose on July 23, 2005, 01:13:48 pm
Sorta. But considering a lot of the Founding Fathers were either Christians or God-fearing people....
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Roger on July 23, 2005, 01:15:31 pm
Quote
Sorta. But considering a lot of the Founding Fathers were either Christians or God-fearing people....
[snapback]209093[/snapback]

My point exactly.  You have to look at the Constitution through the eyes of those who wrote it.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Gideon Brown on July 26, 2005, 02:57:30 pm
Okay, Lynne's coming out of hiding and getting back to debating. I haven't posted in here in over a month, because I had no time during the days, being I had a fulltime job. But now that I have a 25 hour a week job during evenings, I have more time.

First off, as most people who have frequented the debate den in the past year know, I am not Christian. And I enjoy debating if God is real or not, or if Christianity is the one true religion. But I have absolutely no problem with the displaying of the ten commandments. It is other Christian displays that tend to insult me. One billboard near my house once said something like 'repend your sins or suffer eternal ::Dolphin Noise::ation'. That is insulting. But, for the most part, the ten commandments do not insult other religions, except maybe the first.
Let's review them, shall we?
"You shall have no other gods before me"
Yes, this commandment appears to be insulting, but you can always take into context that it is YOUR God being spoke about.
"You shall not make for yourself an idol in the form of anything in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below. You shall not bow down to them or worship them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, punishing the children for the sin of the fathers to the third and fourth generation of those who hate me, but showing love to a thousand {generations} of those who love me and keep my commandments."
Now this one is very insulting, to anyone who is not Christian, and indeed to even some Christians. For what is a statue of the Virgin Mary but not an idol? And some Christians rever her to the highest degree, and God himself said no idols. So if it can insult a Christian, well...I'm okay with it, I guess.
"You shall not misuse the name of the LORD your God, for the LORD will not hold anyone guiltless who misuses his name."
Well, its true. Any God's name should not be taken in vain. But the Christian God's name is often taken in vain, by Christians themselves. This is only a reminder to Christians to stop saying "Jesus CHRIST THAT HURT!"
"Remember the Sabbath day by keeping it holy. Six days you shall labor and do all your work, but the seventh day is a Sabbath to the LORD your God. On it you shall not do any work, neither you, nor your son or daughter, nor your manservant or maidservant, nor your animals, nor the alien within your gates. For in six days the LORD made the heavens and the earth, the sea, and all that is in them, but he rested on the seventh day. Therefore the LORD blessed the Sabbath day and made it holy.
This can be seen as insulting to Jews or Muslims but it's not. For, not only do Christians have a Sabbath, but so do the other two religions (Judaism is Saturday and Islam is Friday). Other religions such as pagan religion might find this insulting, but honestly, this commandment isn't even followed anymore, so who cares?
"Honor your father and your mother, so that you may live long in the land the LORD your God is giving you.
Well, you should definitely honour your parents. To a certain extent. It's just a law telling you to respect your elders.
"You shall not murder."
That's actually a law. You can't murder anyone, or you are either sentenced life or sentenced death. Depending where you live. It's good to have it printed places, just in case you're about to snap, and then you see it.
"You shall not commit adultery."
This affects more than just one religion. This affects morals. What does adultery actually stand for? Sex before marriage. Many Christians practice premarital sex.
 "You shall not steal."
Thanks for the reminder. I really don't need those earrings THAT bad.
"You shall not give false testimony against your neighbor."
Don't lie. It's pretty simple. You were taught that in kindergarten.
"You shall not covet your neighbor's house. You shall not covet your neighbor's wife, or his manservant or maidservant, his ox or donkey, or anything that belongs to your neighbor."
Well, in my opinion this is a good thing. Don't want something you can't have. You'll never have it.

Just to let you know, I found this passage at Bible Gateway (http://www.biblegateway.com) using the New International Version (NIV) Because I could not be bothered going downstairs to find one of my three Bibles. :|
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Elizabeth Rose on July 26, 2005, 07:53:41 pm
Quote
Now this one is very insulting, to anyone who is not Christian, and indeed to even some Christians. For what is a statue of the Virgin Mary but not an idol? And some Christians rever her to the highest degree, and God himself said no idols. So if it can insult a Christian, well...I'm okay with it, I guess.

That's my problem with the Catholic church. And good Christians don't practise pre-marital sex. Unfortunately there are a lot of people that go to church that aren't truly saved. They just grew up going to church, so they keep going "because it's just what you do".
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Gideon Brown on July 26, 2005, 09:19:24 pm
I know many very religious Christians who follow pretty much everything, and believe in God with a fervor, but are in a premarital sex relationship. I also know a very adamant Catholic who is gay, and in a commonlaw marriage (although they will be saying their vows in the near future, now that gay marriages are legal in Canada). I do not judge these people by their sex lives, nor by their religious beliefs. I'm just happy to be their friend. :]

And I also agree with you about the Catholic church. I can not understand how they are the 'original' Christian Church, and yet they themselves do not follow the whole ten commandments.

Oh, and Liz, I am in great respect for you standing up for your religion the way you do. You are very polite. :]
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Elizabeth Rose on July 26, 2005, 09:39:43 pm
Thank you love! I do try to be kind and make a good point at the same time. :)
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: SpongeBass GuitarPants on July 27, 2005, 09:11:15 pm
As you know I have very strong feelings about this sort of thing and you should all know the go about this and I just get out of hand so al I will say is that I think the Ten Commandments should stay UP!
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: Fink on August 01, 2005, 12:28:11 am
Quote
And I also agree with you about the Catholic church. I can not understand how they are the 'original' Christian Church, and yet they themselves do not follow the whole ten commandments.
[snapback]210419[/snapback]

Can you explain what you mean by that? I could tell you about Catholics being the original church, but I don't want to be accused of "shoving my religion down your throat." If you are talking about the Virgin Mary, I'll explain that one. Catholics don't pray to the statue, we pray through it. If you don't understand that one, then ask. The Catholic church is not stupid. I don't think they'd break one of the ten commandments like that.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: GIR on August 01, 2005, 04:50:56 am
Quote
Quote
Now this one is very insulting, to anyone who is not Christian, and indeed to even some Christians. For what is a statue of the Virgin Mary but not an idol? And some Christians rever her to the highest degree, and God himself said no idols. So if it can insult a Christian, well...I'm okay with it, I guess.

That's my problem with the Catholic church. And good Christians don't practise pre-marital sex. Unfortunately there are a lot of people that go to church that aren't truly saved. They just grew up going to church, so they keep going "because it's just what you do".
[snapback]210403[/snapback]
thats what alot of people call playing church.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IceFox on August 13, 2005, 07:56:22 pm
Serperation of Church and state means this:

If our persident is chirsitan, not evryone in the nation has to be. Its like freedom of releigiion. We are not under a particular forced religion.

Anyways, they shouldnt ban its display in public.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: ssj4gogita4 on August 13, 2005, 08:10:39 pm
Everything else is displayed in public. Why not this?
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: MiraclrPlz on August 13, 2005, 08:12:07 pm
Yeah cause this is a Christian Country.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: IZ on August 13, 2005, 08:14:20 pm
Quote
Yeah cause this is a Christian Country.
[snapback]218162[/snapback]

and the Puritans were nice people.
Title: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: ssj4gogita4 on August 13, 2005, 08:15:30 pm
Quote
Yeah cause this is a Christian Country.
[snapback]218162[/snapback]
Haha. Do you listen to yourself? Have you really been attending church?

Not everyone is Christian. Just keep repeating that to yourself.
Title: Re: Displaying Ten Commandements in Public
Post by: cs@charter.net on July 12, 2006, 07:48:57 pm
Why do you need them displayed anyway? Shouldn't you already know them?

It's the commandments like "You shall have no other gods besides Me" that make me disagree with posting it in public. You're basically spitting in the face of every other religion.


You're right, we shold know them ourselves. BUT, (remember) if it isn't your religion, then the words (Thou shall have no other gods before me) are MEANINGLESS

And also, IZ, you note in an earler post that people still kill each other, even though it's a commandment. Does that make it right??